User blog comment:RG4215/Godfrey's Position/@comment-5624498-20121106043513

I'd say 1 & 2 is certainly possible given that we've already seen The Light in possession of Apokaliptian technology (which would explain how they came to acquire it), although it could be 2 with the twist that he really is a Reach operative.

Another possibility: It's No. 3 with a twist in that Godfrey is actively working as an agent of The Light, in which his beliefs are simply him working to sew distrust for the JL among Earth's inhabitants.