Board Thread:Young Justice News/@comment-47881-20130128165351/@comment-1895174-20130323055324

Cari1994 wrote: LoveWaffle wrote:
 * 1) The effort would've been appreciated earlier when it might have mattered.
 * Ok
 * 1) He didn't? I thought it was good, and everyone I've spoken to who's been critical of the episode is critical of it because they thought things were rushed or they didn't like the idea to kill off a character who spent most of the season in the background. But that doesn't make it any less a finale.
 * 2) Has nothing to do with it.
 * 3) You're making little to no sense. I'm not discarding any plot points. I'm not underestimating the complexity and value of the plot. I just see it as conclusive, and I won't invent any plot points so I can view it otherwise. Can you not be satisfied that he gave us a conclusion that was actually conclusive?

And by the way, Season 2 of Young Justice is a masterpiece. Of the superhero shows that I've seen (and that's about all of them), Season 2 of YJ ranks among the best. Don't forget that.
 * 1) The effort was not to prevent the cancellation, but to reverse it. In that case, it still matters.
 * 2) See next point
 * 3) When I say that it didn't satisfy the audience, I mean that it didn't leave a lot of unanswered questions and that it didn't leave them wanting more, not that they didn't like it.
 * 4) Again, read my response to Regulus. It has everything to do with my next point.
 * 5) You may not be intentionally underestimating the complexity and value of the plot, but by discarding the questions left by the "Darkseid/Light" plot point and the "implied new dystopian future" plot point, you're making them seem less intriguing and important than they're supposed to be and since everything in the series plot is connected, you're unintentionally making other plot points seem less important than they're supposed to be.
 * 6) I never denied that this season was a masterpiece. I meant that while an artist might never be done with their work, he can be done with a piece of work. Greg surely can make a season finale that works as a series finale, but this wasn't it.

With that being said, this discussion is done. Done, done, done, done, done!
 * 1) If the effort was used to prevent the cancellation, then no further effort would be needed.
 * OK
 * 1) You have it backwards - people were not satisfied with the content itself. As for wrapping things up, the only complaint was that there was the tease at the end. Otherwise, everything's been concluded.
 * 2) It has nothing to do with it. You are grasping at straws and unfairly extrapolating on what we have seen.
 * 3) Again, you're forgetting that I'm not discarding any plots or underestimating the complexity of the plot. I just see it as concluded. You, on the other hand, must invent lingering plot points (like a new dystopian future) for the sake of your own argument.
 * 4) He made a season finale that was worthy of being a series finale. It aired about a week ago.