User blog comment:Aslan10000/New Joker Voice./@comment-1038387-20120101105947

Why should they recast him? I didn't like Brent Spiner at first, but watching him do Puck in Gargoyles did help. nonetheless, my two cents:
 * Kevin Michael Richardson: God please no
 * John Dimaggio: He wasn't that bad, though it'd take some getting used to
 * James Patrick Stewart: for his role as Jester in Crisis on Two Earths? I liked that, don't know if it would work for this Joker.
 * Dan Castella[ta]? I'm not familiar with his full range, but I'm going to say no.
 * David Tennet. The Doctor? Why?
 * Rob Paulson/Paulsen: Not really.
 * Phil LaMarr: He's not that good at maniacal white guys.
 * Tom Kenny: I'm fed up with his voice.
 * Tom Kane: I was fed up with his voice far before Tom Kenny.
 * Steve Blum: He's got that beautiful rasp in his voice, it's a shame if he did the Joker.
 * Nolan North: Already does a lot in the show, and they're starting to sound similar.


 * Grey Delisle: Please no. I disliked her in the short, and Grey DeLisle is one of those voices I just heard enough of. Especially if she plays someone younger than she is. And she's 38, only 4 years younger than Vanessa Marshall. They could've gone for a younger voice, but Grey DeLisle would be terrible.