Board Thread:Episodic and Issue Discussion/@comment-47881-20130218203024/@comment-6422326-20130220000336

Ninja 989 wrote: Lorisa214 wrote:

Regulus22 wrote:

69.117.58.49 wrote:

Ratrangerm wrote: Since it was discussed in the previous thread, I'll continue it here:

What people are forgetting about the Reach and the Scarab is the two times Blue Beetle has been revealed to the public as responsible for something was in times in which he was going against another aggressor. Thus the Reach can portray things as Beetle protecting the public from other threats.

The public has never seen Blue Beetle go solely on the offensive, only to respond to a threat or to help other people. The Reach can claim either as "peaceful" intent.

"Peaceful" does not mean that when somebody attacks you, you give no response and keep holding up two fingers. Yet the scarab is still a weapon, whatever it is being used for. Just because you are using a gun to defend yourself against a murder doesn't mean that it is any less a weapon than if you used it to assasinate the president. Fists are/were classified as weapons in France. You can't persecute someone for possessing such a weapon when it's a part of them, as with the Reach it's as bonded as the hand to a Frenchman, only when used as such. In Canada if you're a 3rd degree black belt, you are considered a registered weapon. (you have to register at the police station before you can get to that level) Plus they are in America! They have very limited gun laws. If Superman doesn't have to register himself, then BB doesn't. (Unless being apart of the JL is the equivalent of that??) Just got an account. But my point had NOTHING to do with registering!!!! It was simply about the Reach saying that they had no weapons and couldn't help us against Warworld, yet then turning around and saying, "We gave the person who saved your planet from Warworld his weapon." It is contradictory. I just used the gun as an EXAMPLE of how the scarab was still a weapon even if it was USED to defend the Earth. i rewatched the war episode, the reach told the press they only had  a single ship which they used for exploration and it is w/o weapon