Robin and his squad were doing a routine check on Mad Hatter, who was recently released from Arkham Asylum. After Robin discovered the crook left clay behind, Orphan rushed ahead and cut Mad Hatter in two with her sword - revealing him to be Clayface. They followed him to a warehouse, where the real Mad Hatter oversaw Blackwater metahuman smuggling ring. The squad fought the mind-controlled Clayface, but Mad Hatter blew up the warehouse as he escaped. Orphan and the others made it out safely.